Skip to main content

Table 2 Studies included

From: Conducting co-creation for public health in low and middle-income countries: a systematic review and key informant perspectives on implementation barriers and facilitators

Authors

Year

Country

Public health issue

Challenge addressed

Stakeholders involved

Aim

Chenais et al. [32]

2023

Uganda

African swine fever

African swine fever (ASF) spread along the smallholder value chain.

Community members, including all value chain stakeholders, including pig farmers, traders, slaughter slab operators, butchers, pork vendors and pork joint owners

To investigate the capacity of participatory action at the community level for improved biosecurity in the smallholder pig value chain in Northern Uganda.

Maureithi et al. [33]

2023

Malawi

HIV prevention

Need to develop digital health applications fitting contextual resource constraints.

HIV patients, healthcare workers, clinical and evaluation team

To design a text-based system of tailored reminders and messages.

Robbins et al. [34]

2022

Haiti and Zimbabwe

Pre-eclampsia

High maternal mortality ratios in Haiti and Zimbabwe.

Community members,

health professionals, representatives from non-governmental organizations (NGOs)

and representatives from the ministries of health

To develop culturally relevant, context-specific educational resources through interdisciplinary collaboration and community engagement.

Ilozumba et al. [35]

2022

Uganda

Cancer prevention

Low use of interactive voice response (IVR) technology for cancer information provision.

People living with cancer, health workers, professional roles (doctors, oncologists, nurses, etc.) and policy makers (e.g., from the Ministry of Health and other regulatory bodies)

To develop a program theory for a co-created IVR system for cancer awareness in Uganda.

Willetts et al. [36]

2022

Indonesia

Climate change and sanitation

Impact of climate-related hazards and impact on sanitation systems.

City governments

To co-produce a research process with local governments.

Almeida et al. [37]

2022

Brazil, Paraguay, and Argentina

Alcohol, tobacco, and cannabis consumption.

Regions of the study report a high percentage of criminal activity and economic disadvantage.

Researchers and representatives of the target population

To co-develop activities as part of an intersectoral intervention tackling alcohol, tobacco, and cannabis consumption among teenagers.

Corburn et al. [38]

2022

Kenya

Climate change, WASH, flooding.

Urban informal settlements or slums are among the most vulnerable to climate-related health risks.

Researchers, community members and representatives of the target population

To co-create an innovative climate justice plan.

Tahlil et al. [39]

2022

Nigeria

HIV prevention

Low uptake of HIV testing services and poor rates of linkage to care.

Researchers and community members

To develop HIV self-testing (HIVST) strategies for potential implementation in their local communities.

Banerjee et al. [40]

2022

India

Vaccine campaigns

Population resistance to vaccine campaigns.

Community members, stakeholders and faith leaders.

To co-design interventions to address vaccine hesitancy.

Nwaozuru et al. [41]

2021

Nigeria

HIV

Low uptake of HIV testing services and poor rates of linkage to care.

Young people, health professionals, activists, and entrepreneurs.

To develop a deep understanding of their needs and to maximize user satisfaction with HIV services.

Hartmann et al. [42]

2021

South Africa

HIV prevention

Low uptake of HIV testing services and poor rates of linkage to care.

Youth

To develop long-acting biomedical HIV prevention programs.

Shahmanesh et al. [43]

2021

South Africa

HIV prevention

Low uptake of HIV testing services and poor rates of linkage to care.

Youth

To develop a peer-led biosocial intervention for HIV prevention.

Anwar et al. [44]

2021

Egypt

HIV

Fishermen have limited access to health services and may have various health literacy-related difficulties that may lead to poor health outcomes.

Fishermen and health workers

To co-design health literacy interventions with the aim of improving health and equity outcomes.

Boateng et al. [45]

2021

Ghana

Health literacy in

management of malaria

Struggle to eradicate malaria in Ghana and high rates of positivity to disease in children under five years old.

Target population and relevant stakeholders.

To develop a health literacy intervention for Ghana caregivers concerning managing malaria in children under five years.

Yadav et al. [46]

2021

Nepal

Multi-morbid chronic

obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)

Nepal has the highest prevalence of

COPD in South Asia.

Persons with COPD and

their family members; healthcare providers and other stakeholders, including community leaders,

representatives from

government.

To develop an integrated model of care for people with multi-morbid

COPD in rural Nepal.

Echaubard et al. [47]

2020

Cambodia

Dengue and dengue control

Dengue is the most rapidly spreading mosquito-borne

viral disease in the world and is strongly related to urban expansion worldwide, particularly in tropical regions.

Teachers, school directors and Ministry of Education representatives and students.

To operationalize and sustain community-led dengue control operations.

Brakema et al. [48]

2020

Kyrgyzstan and Vietnam

Chronic respiratory diseases

A high number of death rates to chronic respiratory diseases in LMICs

Researchers and Community members

To study the feasibility, acceptability, and effectiveness of translating

an awareness programme targeting risks to Cardiorespiratory diseases to

Kyrgyzstan and Vietnam.

Santina et al. [49]

2020

Lebanon

Childhood obesity

In Lebanon, 31.4% of children aged 5–19 years were reported to be overweight

or obese.

Community members

To increase the moderate to vigorous physical activity (PA) level at school among Lebanese children aged 10–12.

Lazo-Porras et al. [50]

2020

Peru

Chronic diseases at the primary healthcare level

85% of premature deaths due to non-

communicable diseases (NCDs) occur in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs).

Community members, health workers, and policymakers

To develop interventions aimed at improving diagnosis and/or management of chronic diseases at the primary healthcare level.

Crosby et al. [51]

2020

India, Sierra Leone

Hand-hygiene

The potential of hand-hygiene strategies to control disease transmission.

Research team and stakeholders, including teachers and collaborators.

To adapt culturally relevant resources for hand-hygiene awareness.

Draper et al. [52]

2019

South Africa

Obesity prevention

Increase obesity levels.

Community members

To co-develop a healthy lifestyle programme for low-income, black South Africans through churches.

Person et al. [53]

2016

Tanzania

Urogenital schistosomiasis control

Lack of effectiveness of previous interventions.

Target population and relevant stakeholders.

To develop and implement interventions to track local infections.